Skip to content
SEO

How to fix broken links during an SEO audit

12/02/2025
Optimize digital data for clear visibility

Performing an SEO audit is a cornerstone of any successful online marketing strategy. It’s a deep dive into your website’s health, identifying areas for improvement that can boost your rankings, improve user experience, and ultimately drive more organic traffic. One of the most often overlooked, yet surprisingly impactful, aspects of an audit is the examination of your website’s internal and external linking structure. Broken links – those that lead to 404 errors or other unavailable pages – aren’t just frustrating for visitors; they actively harm your SEO by negatively impacting your crawl budget, hurting your domain authority, and creating a poor user experience. Ignoring them is essentially handing your competitors a significant advantage. This article will guide you through how to identify, analyze, and fix broken links during your SEO audit, ensuring your website remains healthy and effective.

Identifying Broken Links

The first step is recognizing that you even have broken links. Thankfully, there are several tools available to automate this process. Manual inspection is possible, but incredibly time-consuming, particularly for larger websites. Utilizing a dedicated broken link checker is far more efficient. Tools like Screaming Frog, Ahrefs Site Audit, and SEMrush Site Audit crawl your website and identify any URLs that return an error code. These tools not only pinpoint broken links but also provide valuable context – which pages are linking to them, how many times they’re linking, and the overall impact of the broken link on your site’s structure. Consider using a combination of tools; some may uncover different types of broken links than others, providing a more comprehensive assessment of the issue. Keeping a detailed spreadsheet of identified broken links is also crucial for organization and tracking your progress.

Categorizing Broken Links: Internal vs. External

Once you’ve identified the broken links, it’s crucial to categorize them. You’ll primarily encounter two types: internal and external. Internal broken links are those pointing to pages that no longer exist within your own website. These typically occur when a page is deleted, moved, or significantly restructured. Addressing internal broken links is generally easier as you have direct control over the fixes. External broken links, on the other hand, point to links on other websites – those you don’t control. These require a different approach, often involving contacting the website owner to request a redirect. Understanding this distinction is vital for prioritizing your efforts and applying the appropriate fix. A large number of internal links will require a site-wide update, while external links might be more scattered and require individual outreach.

Fixing Internal Broken Links: Redirects and Updates

Optimize digital content for improved success

The primary solution for internal broken links is typically implementing 301 redirects. A 301 redirect permanently moves a page to a new URL, preserving the link juice and informing search engines that the content has moved. This is the best practice for ensuring that users and search engines are directed to the correct, updated page. When implementing redirects, ensure they are configured correctly in your server’s .htaccess file or your CMS (Content Management System). It’s crucial to test each redirect thoroughly to confirm it’s working as intended. If a page has been completely removed and doesn’t have a suitable replacement, consider rewriting the content and creating a new page with similar keywords and attributes. Failing to address these internal broken links can significantly damage your site’s crawlability and overall ranking potential.

Fixing External Broken Links: Outreach and Replacement

Dealing with external broken links requires a slightly different strategy. For a significant number of broken external links, a mass email campaign to the website owners is often the most practical approach. Keep your email concise, polite, and informative, clearly stating that your website has a broken link to their page and requesting a redirect or a suitable replacement. However, be prepared for a low response rate – many website owners are unaware of broken links on their sites. In some cases, you might need to manually replace the broken link with a link to a relevant, similar resource on your own website. Alternatively, if you’re linking to a resource that provides valuable information, you could suggest the website owner improve the link to their own page instead. Prioritize fixing the most impactful external broken links first – those linking to high-authority websites or pages with relevant keywords.

Conclusion

Fixing broken links is a vital part of any comprehensive SEO audit and contributes significantly to a healthier, more effective website. By systematically identifying, categorizing, and diligently addressing both internal and external broken links, you’ll improve user experience, boost crawl efficiency, and ultimately enhance your search engine rankings. Don’t underestimate the power of a clean and functional linking structure – it’s a fundamental aspect of strong SEO performance and a key factor in driving organic traffic. Regularly scheduled audits, coupled with a proactive approach to link maintenance, will keep your website performing at its best.